February 20, 2013   30 notes

According to The Guardian, a line of tough questioning during the Oscar Pistorius bail hearing has damaged the prosecution's case against the Olympic runner. More details on the questioning of detective Hilton Botha:

thecallus:

shortformblog:

Botha initially asserted that he had found two boxes of “steroids” in Pistorius’s bedroom, hastily changing this to “two boxes of testosterone, needles and injections”. Later, questioned by advocate Barry Roux for the defence, Botha had to admit he could not be certain of the contents. Roux said it was a “herbal remedy” called testo-composutim co-enzyme used by many athletes, insisting: “It is not a steroid and it is not a banned substance.”

Botha also told the court one of his witnesses had heard a fight, “two people talking loudly at each other”, between 2 and 3am on 14 February. But, pressured by Roux, he conceded that the witness had not identified the voices as belonging to Pistorius and Steenkamp and lived some 600 metres away. There was a collective murmur from Pistorius’s family. Botha later changed his estimate to 300 metres when questioned by the prosecution.

Botha acknowledged that Pistorius’s legal team had found a spent bullet cartridge in the toilet bowl that his officers did not. He also confronted Botha, saying: “You were in the house walking with unprotected shoes. That should not happen.” Botha conceded that it should not.

Botha said police found two iPhones in the bathroom and two BlackBerrys in the bedroom, adding that none had been used to phone for help. But Roux claimed the defence team had another phone in its possession that the police had failed to request. “Why did you not come to us and ask for Pistorius’s cellphone number?” he asked.

Roux also took him to task for failing to check Pistorius’s claim that he phoned the Netcare hospital at 3.20am.

Botha said ammunition for a .38-calibre weapon had been found at the house but Pistorius did not hold a licence for it. “Did you take steps to find out who the owner of the ammunition was?” Roux demanded. Botha replied: “No, I didn’t.”

“I feel like the court proceedings went well today,” said Pistorius’ brother, Carl. ”We trust that everyone has more clarity about this tragic incident.”

Brutal. So the steroids bit, the time line, the actions in the immediate aftermath, and the domestic event precursor components of the case all suffer badly. Maybe Pistorius isn’t a horrible piece of shit!

All I know is that when I’m robbing somebody’s house I make a point of locking myself in the bathroom because when you got to go you got to go and if somebody is in the bathroom in the middle of the night, Occam’s razor says it’s either a robber or Santa Clause, but either way shoot first.

The rest of the evidence will come out in time—but there doesn’t seem to be anything in there that is particularly damaging to the prosecution, possibly excluding ambiguity about the distance.

(via thecallus-deactivated20130520)

  1. newstothepoint reblogged this from shortformblog
  2. sophichka reblogged this from shortformblog
  3. kaliem reblogged this from shortformblog
  4. jollygoodtime reblogged this from shortformblog and added:
    Whats really starting to piss me off about the reporting of this case is that every time there’s a headline its from the...
  5. sensiblestupidity reblogged this from shortformblog
  6. sooimsydney reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  7. cityandcdour reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  8. foronceiamquitecomfortable reblogged this from shortformblog
  9. apoplecticskeptic reblogged this from squashedcomments
  10. starchildnoodles reblogged this from shortformblog
  11. basednkrumah reblogged this from shortformblog and added:
    Yaweh, if he somehow gets off scott-free I won’t be surprised.
  12. shortformblog posted this